LatestPakistan

PA speaker urges political parties to debate creation of new provinces

Says public opinion must be considered alongside assemblies’ constitutional authority

Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan. PHOTO: FACEBOOK/Malik Ahmed Khan


LAHORE:

Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan on Wednesday called on political parties to hold dialogue on the creation of new provinces, saying the constitutional authority to establish them rested with the assemblies but public opinion on the matter could not be ignored.

Addressing a press conference at the Punjab Assembly, he said the Constitution provided a mechanism for seeking public opinion through a referendum under Article 48, arguing that discussing the creation of new provinces was neither unconstitutional nor a subject that should be treated as taboo. He urged political parties to sit together and debate the issue, particularly in light of recent remarks by Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.

Bilawal delivered a hard-hitting speech at the Karachi Press Club, calling for a “political reset” and criticising the government over its handling of governance and constitutional matters. The PPP chairman rejected proposals to hold a referendum on the creation of new provinces, questioning the intent behind the move and warning that any attempt to divide Sindh against the wishes of its people could lead to bloodshed.

Questioning the PPP’s differing positions on the division of Punjab and Sindh, Malik recalled that the Punjab Assembly had unanimously passed a resolution in favour of dividing Punjab in May 2012, when the PPP was in power. However, he said, the party had walked out when the division of Sindh was discussed.

The speaker said the debate over new provinces stemmed from concerns about the unequal distribution of resources, disparities in public spending between major cities and remote areas, poor governance and the failure to devolve powers to elected local representatives.

He questioned whether a chief minister could effectively govern a province as large as Punjab, saying the concerns of people in distant areas, particularly regarding education and access to public services, required serious consideration. He stressed that the issue was not simply about creating new provinces but also about ensuring people’s constitutional right to govern themselves and receive a fair share of resources.

Read More: ‘Are your hands clean?’: Khawaja Asif hits back at Bilawal over govt criticism

Referring to Article 48, Malik said the constitutional provision could not be declared unconstitutional, as it was part of the Constitution framed under the leadership of former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and the then National Assembly.

He described a referendum as an opportunity for people, whom he called the ultimate sovereign authority after Allah, to express their views on the matter. However, he clarified that the decision to hold a referendum rested with political party leadership, while the creation of new provinces fell within the assemblies’ authority.

Malik added that a new province could not be imposed if people opposed its creation, while their support would also have to be taken into account.

Reiterating his position that democracy required dialogue, he said political differences should be resolved through discussion. Referring to referendums held by former presidents, he said those exercises had faced serious public objections and that Article 48(3) required proper interpretation.

Responding to Bilawal’s remarks about political prisoners, Malik said describing someone as a political prisoner did not automatically make every action committed by that individual a legitimate political right.

Questioning how the burning of houses and attacks on 29 cantonments could be regarded as political activity, he described the incidents as part of a planned conspiracy rather than the exercise of legitimate political rights. “If attacks on 29 cantonments in a country are accepted as political activity, Pakistan cannot continue to exist in its present form,” he said.

Also Read: Bilawal will be responsible for any bloodshed over new provinces: Kamal

However, the speaker praised Bilawal’s parliamentary speeches during the May 2025 Pakistan-India conflict, particularly his response to India’s allegations over the Pahalgam incident. He said the PPP chairman had effectively defended Pakistan’s position and that he attached considerable importance to his views.

Malik also described the execution of former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto as a wrongful judicial decision, saying military rulers and flawed judicial decisions had caused serious damage to the country.

Expressing his expectations of Bilawal, Malik said democratic leaders should remain willing to reconsider their positions through dialogue.

Reiterating the need for political reconciliation, he said differences of opinion should not deprive anyone of the right to ask questions. Recalling his own questions about those who had supported the process of Talibanisation, he stressed that political and religious leaders should be willing to engage in open discussions.

He urged political parties to convene a roundtable to discuss their differences, warning that political decisions carried consequences and that political reactions could even lead to an emergency.

Referring to the security situation, Malik said bomb blasts had deeply affected him and stressed that peace needed to be restored before meaningful discussions on the state, politics and democracy could take place.

Politicians respond to Bilawal’s address

Bilawal’s remarks drew a mixed response from the government and opposition, with several political figures challenging his criticism of the existing system and his position on a referendum.

Adviser to the Prime Minister on Political Affairs Rana Sanaullah said the PPP chairman’s comments about the 27th Constitutional Amendment being passed under pressure could provide grounds for his disqualification as a lawmaker.

He pointed out that the PPP had been part of the coalition government and had participated in every stage of the legislative process, including the passage of the 26th and 27th amendments. Sanaullah also questioned whether Bilawal was implying that he had cast his vote under someone’s influence, rather than of his own free will.

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar, meanwhile, defended the proposed referendum, saying it was a constitutional and legal way to ascertain public opinion on the creation of new provinces. He said the debate on governance and administrative reforms should not be suppressed and questioned why political parties should object to asking people what they wanted.

Tarar also reminded Bilawal that the PPP was part of the same government, saying political parties that had been in power for decades could not distance themselves from the weaknesses of the existing system. He further criticised what he called the contradiction of political parties enjoying government positions and privileges while presenting themselves as opposition.

The opposition response was more supportive of Bilawal’s criticism, though some parties questioned the PPP’s own record. Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) spokesperson Aslam Ghauri welcomed his remarks, saying the PPP chairman had endorsed the party’s position that a referendum was unnecessary where the Constitution already provided a mechanism to resolve an issue.

The Tehreek-e-Tahafuz-e-Ain Pakistan also welcomed his comments in principle but said there was a contradiction between the PPP’s words and actions, urging Bilawal to translate his statements into practical steps. PTI, however, said the PPP could not absolve itself of responsibility for the country’s economic and political situation while remaining part of the ruling coalition.

Party spokesperson Sheikh Waqas Akram also criticised Bilawal for supporting the 26th Amendment and demanded that the PPP help secure the return of PTI’s reserved seats if it was serious about democratic representation.

28th Amendment and proposed referendum

The proposed 28th Constitutional Amendment has been discussed in the context of reorganising Pakistan’s administrative structure and creating additional provinces, with reports suggesting a possible plan to divide the country into 12 provinces.

One proposal reportedly envisaged dividing Punjab into four provinces, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each, and Sindh into two. However, no final draft or formally approved 28th Amendment has been presented, and the proposal remains part of the political debate.

A referendum, meanwhile, is a direct vote in which citizens are asked to express their views on a particular question. The idea of holding one on the creation of new provinces was floated by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who argued that it could help establish public opinion on the issue and settle the debate.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button