HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ reboot faces criticism after new Great Hall scene is released
The preview has received largely negative responses online over the filming style, colour grading and atmosphere
HBO’s upcoming Harry Potter television adaptation has faced fresh criticism after a new scene from the series was shared online, prompting viewers to question its visual style and atmosphere.
The newly released footage, shared by HBO Max UK and Ireland on YouTube, shows Harry Potter and fellow Hogwarts students enjoying a banquet in the Great Hall.
The scene also features John Lithgow as Albus Dumbledore and Janet McTeer as Professor McGonagall discussing Harry’s resemblance to his father, James Potter.
However, the preview has received a largely negative response on social media.
One X user questioned the filming style, writing, “Why’s it filmed like an SNL skit?”
Another viewer compared the scene to an advertisement rather than a television production, while a third described it as “absolute slop that should not exist”.
Other reactions focused on the scene’s colour grading and atmosphere.
One user commented, “It looks very cold. I like the organic warmth of the original’s grading”. Television writer and comedian Chase Mitchell also criticised the footage, highlighting what he called a “profound” sense of questioning why the remake was being made.
The best way to describe the new Harry Potter series is that they all look like they’re fully aware that they’re in a Harry Potter series https://t.co/MFbJUhpvsb
— LilMoonLambo (@LilMoonLambo) November 15, 2026
Even if JK Rowling was some squeaky clean trans activist, i’d still view this in the same way I view the 2026 Moana “remake”.
A vile, desperate, artless, corporate, slopfest that nobody in their right mind should support if they want good art to be popular. https://t.co/bF7LRe3duF
— Haydritch (@TheHaydra5) November 15, 2026
disregarding jk rowling, this also just looks like actual shit compared to a movie that released twenty years ago and had a smaller budget https://t.co/IvMyWmhlEz
— Cameron (@camcam2455) November 15, 2026
The series will star Dominic McLaughlin, Alastair Stout and Arabella Stanton as Harry, Ron and Hermione, respectively. Nick Frost will play Hagrid, while Paapa Essiedu takes on the role of Severus Snape.
The adaptation has already attracted criticism following its first trailer in March, with some fans questioning its visual appeal and whether it captures the charm of the original films.
The actor set to portray Lord Voldemort has yet to be announced.